Is AI Really Essential or The Human Touch in Music: My Experience
The growing influence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and digital technology in music has made me reflect on a simple question: Are we using technology to enrich music, or are we gradually allowing it to replace the human effort that makes music meaningful?
My reflection comes from my everyday experience as a Hindustani classical musician, teacher and researcher. My morning usually begins with Riyaz. Recently, I started my day practising the swaras, alankars and palte of Raga Bhairav. During my hour-long drive to the university, I listened to melodies from 1990s Bollywood, followed by a Thumri and a Khayal in Raga Todi. At the university, students performed Raga Yaman in their practical examination at 9:30 a.m. Although Yaman is traditionally associated with the evening, the students performed well, and we continued practising a Bandish in the same raga. Later, I spent another hour singing Raga Miyan Ki Todi, followed by listening to Khayal in Raga Kamod. Each experience brought a different musical mood and response. I have noticed that I can listen to older Bollywood songs, Dhrupad, Khayal and Thumri for several hours, sometimes throughout the day, without feeling irritated. As a music student, I can also practise a raga for three to four hours in one sitting. However, some contemporary songs, particularly those released in recent years, seem to make me feel restless or tired after prolonged listening. This is my personal observation, not a scientifically established fact. Individual listening preferences differ, and contemporary music also offers many meaningful and expressive compositions. Nevertheless, this experience has encouraged me to think about the changing aesthetics and production practices of popular music.
Much of the older film music was created through live orchestras, instrumentalists, rehearsals, live sound arrangements and collaborative recording processes. Individual musicians' contributions, natural variations in performance, and interaction between instruments gave these recordings a distinctive character. The knowledge and skills involved were developed through years of practice and direct musical experience. In Hindustani classical music, this connection is even more significant. Riyaz, Shruti awareness, accurate swara intonation, improvisation and the Guru-Shishya tradition require sustained discipline. A raga is not simply a collection of notes; it is an evolving musical expression shaped by grammar, imagination, aesthetics, and the performer’s individual identity. Today, the music industry is undergoing a significant transformation. DAWs, digital loops, virtual instruments, electronic tuners, pitch correction and AI-based tools can generate beats, melodies, arrangements and even vocals within minutes. They can also assist with lyrics, mixing and mastering. These developments have made production more accessible, efficient and economical. However, when digital loops replace live instrumentalists and programmed arrangements take the place of orchestras, we must also consider the impact on session musicians, accompanists, traditional instrument makers and other skilled professionals whose livelihoods depend on music. The convenience of technology should not make their contribution invisible.
There is also a question of musical learning. AI-assisted tuners and vocal enhancement applications can help students identify pitch-related errors, but can they develop the internal understanding of swara and Shruti that comes through disciplined Riyaz? A student must learn to listen, recognise, reproduce and correct a note independently. Technology can provide feedback, but musical sensitivity develops through practice and experience. Excessive dependence on automated correction may reduce opportunities to develop these essential skills. We are also encountering an increasing volume of AI-generated music on platforms such as YouTube, often presented under labels such as deep-sleep music, healing sounds and meditation music. Such music may offer useful listening experiences for some people, but its intended purpose or digital label alone cannot establish its therapeutic value. Similarly, technical perfection does not automatically guarantee emotional depth or aesthetic quality. The concern is not that every AI-generated composition sounds mechanical or lacks emotion, but that repeated dependence on common loops, patterns and automated arrangements could encourage musical uniformity and reduce opportunities for individual interpretation. Academic institutions and music educators are also exploring AI and digital technologies. This is necessary as the industry evolves. However, we must ensure that technological training does not come at the cost of traditional musicianship, live performance, instrument-making, creative independence and the transmission of musical knowledge. Can AI-generated beats, melodies and instrumental arrangements replace centuries of musical tradition, the expressive depth of Dhrupad, Khayal and Thumri, or the creative freedom of improvisation within a raga? These questions deserve serious academic discussion and systematic research.
I am not against AI, digital music or technological advancement. I believe these tools can support musicians, improve accessibility and create new possibilities. But they should remain instruments in the hands of musicians, not substitutes for musical understanding, human creativity and artistic experience. Perhaps the real question is not whether AI is essential, but whether we are becoming so dependent on it that we risk forgetting the value of human musicianship.
The Sanskrit verse by Bhartihar's Nitshatakam offers a meaningful reminder of the place of arts and knowledge in human life:
साहित्यसङ्गीतकलाविहीनः साक्षात्पशुः पुच्छविषाणहीनः ।
तृणं न खादन्नपि जीवमानस्तद्भागधेयं परमं पशूनाम् ॥
Sāhitya-saṅgīta-kalā-vihīnaḥ sākṣāt-paśuḥ puccha-viṣāṇa-hīnaḥ |
Tṛṇaṁ na khādann-api jīvamānas-tad-bhāgadheyaṁ paramaṁ paśūnām ||
Meaning: A person devoid of literature, music and the arts is like an animal, except that they have neither a tail nor horns. Although such a person does not eat grass, living without these forms of knowledge and artistic expression is considered the unfortunate condition of an animal.
The verse reminds us that literature, music and the arts are not merely forms of entertainment; they are essential dimensions of human sensitivity, understanding and cultural life. If AI generates music, it means humans are abstaining from creating it
Let us embrace technological advancement, but not at the cost of our musical heritage. Let us continue to practise, listen to live music, appreciate Raga Sangeet, support instrumentalists, preserve traditional instrument-making and encourage the next generation to develop genuine musical skills.
Be wise. Use technology, but preserve the human touch. Save music, save musical skills and support musicians.
Disclaimer: This is my personal experience and no conflict of interest with any of the music category or genre









